Crustless Pizza Bowl
9″ bowl with pizza cheese and sauce. Add your favorite toppings.
Each veggie topping $1.45 · Each meat topping $1.90
Base price: check the online ordering menu.
The 2026 menu
Our menu
Pizza, wings, subs, burgers, and something sweet to finish. Find your favorites below or download our full restaurant menu.
Build your own pizza
Our pizza cheese is made with buffalo milk!
| Price per pizza / topping | Personal 8″ | Small 10″ | Medium 12″ | Large 14″ | X Large 16″ | Cauliflower 10″ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese pizza | $7.35 | $10.35 | $12.25 | $14.75 | $17.85 | $13.95 |
| Each veggie topping | $1.35 | $1.55 | $2.15 | $2.85 | $3.15 | $2.29 |
| Each meat topping | $1.85 | $2.15 | $2.65 | $3.65 | $4.35 | $2.45 |
Fruit & veggie toppings
Mushroom · Onion · Green Pepper · Tomato · Banana Pepper · Black Olive · Red Onion · Pineapple · Jalapeño · Pickle · Lettuce
Meat toppings
Pepperoni · Ezzo Pepperoni · Bacon · Ham · Sausage · Salami · Grilled Chicken · Fried Chicken · Taco Beef · Hamburger
Giant 24″ Party Cheese Pizza $26.95
Serves 8–10 people.
Each veggie topping $4.75 · Each meat topping $5.75
Specialty pizzas
Bacon Chicken Ranch
Garlic sauce, bacon, grilled chicken, onion and ranch dressing.
- Personal 8″
- $12.55
- Small 10″
- $17.75
- Medium 12″
- $20.25
- Large 14″
- $23.25
- X Large 16″
- $26.75
- Cauliflower 10″
- $21.75
- Crustless 9″
- $13.35
Stromboli $21.85
Nashville Hot Chicken
Spicy garlic sauce, pickles, fried chicken and Nashville hot sauce.
- Personal 8″
- $12.45
- Small 10″
- $17.65
- Medium 12″
- $20.15
- Large 14″
- $23.25
- X Large 16″
- $26.55
- Cauliflower 10″
- $21.75
- Crustless 9″
- $13.35
Italian Pizza
Ham, salami, pepperoni, onion, banana pepper, lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing.
- Personal 8″
- $13.45
- Small 10″
- $18.75
- Medium 12″
- $21.85
- Large 14″
- $24.95
- X Large 16″
- $29.15
- Cauliflower 10″
- $23.95
- Crustless 9″
- $14.25
All The Way
Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, mushroom, onion, banana pepper, black olives and green peppers.
- Personal 8″
- $15.05
- Small 10″
- $20.15
- Medium 12″
- $25.15
- Large 14″
- $28.15
- X Large 16″
- $30.55
- Cauliflower 10″
- $24.45
- Crustless 9″
- $15.25
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple and bacon.
- Personal 8″
- $12.44
- Small 10″
- $16.15
- Medium 12″
- $19.45
- Large 14″
- $23.15
- X Large 16″
- $26.45
- Cauliflower 10″
- $21.75
- Crustless 9″
- $13.75
Meat Lover’s
Bacon, ham, sausage, and both styles of pepperoni.
- Personal 8″
- $14.15
- Small 10″
- $19.15
- Medium 12″
- $22.15
- Large 14″
- $25.15
- X Large 16″
- $29.15
- Cauliflower 10″
- $23.15
- Crustless 9″
- $15.95
Taco Pizza
Salsa, taco beef, taco seasoning, colby jack cheese, onions, jalapeños, lettuce and tomatoes.
- Personal 8″
- $13.25
- Small 10″
- $17.65
- Medium 12″
- $19.25
- Large 14″
- $20.95
- X Large 16″
- $23.25
- Cauliflower 10″
- $23.95
- Crustless 9″
- $14.25
BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, red onions and pizza cheese.
- Personal 8″
- $12.65
- Small 10″
- $17.65
- Medium 12″
- $19.15
- Large 14″
- $20.15
- X Large 16″
- $21.45
- Cauliflower 10″
- $22.15
- Crustless 9″
- $13.55
Buffalo Chicken
Medium Buffalo wing sauce, grilled chicken and pizza cheese.
- Personal 8″
- $12.65
- Small 10″
- $17.65
- Medium 12″
- $19.15
- Large 14″
- $20.15
- X Large 16″
- $21.45
- Cauliflower 10″
- $22.05
- Crustless 9″
- $13.75
Hot Honey Double Pepperoni
Your choice of double pepperoni finished with a drizzle of hot honey sauce.
- Personal 8″
- $13.45
- Small 10″
- $17.95
- Medium 12″
- $19.35
- Large 14″
- $20.85
- X Large 16″
- $22.25
- Cauliflower 10″
- $22.35
- Crustless 9″
- $14.99
Combos
Six combos, each one a meal — a main, a side, and a cold drink.
Special Combo #1$10.99
Personal size one-topping pizza, bag of chips or garden salad, and bottled water or a choice of Pepsi product.
Special Combo #2$9.99
Small sub combo: choice of cold meat, Italian, or ham and cheese sub with a bag of chips and a choice of Pepsi product or bottled water.
Special Combo #3$11.99
Gibeyes Wrap with breaded chicken breast, lettuce, Colby Jack cheese, red onion and tomatoes, spun in your favorite wing sauce, with chips and a Pepsi product or bottled water.
Special Combo #4$7.99
Breaded chicken breast sandwich with lettuce, tomato, mayo, choice of cheese and pickles. Add your favorite wing sauce to spice it up! Includes a bag of chips and a Pepsi product or bottled water.
Special Combo #5$9.99
Large chef salad with two dressings of your choice, a bag of chips, and a Pepsi product or bottled water.
Special Combo #6$12.99
6 bone-in wings with a garden salad, choice of wing sauce, and bottled water or a Pepsi product.
Subs & sandwiches
Add fries to any sandwich or sub for $4.55.
- Cold Meat Sub
- Small $6.85 · Large $8.25
- Italian Sub
- Small $7.05 · Large $10.05
- Ham & Cheese Sub
- Small $7.05 · Large $10.05
- Meatball Sub
- Small $8.25 · Large $11.25
- Pizza Sub
- $10.15
- Club Sandwich
- Small $7.89 · Large $10.99
- Fish Sandwich
- $9.25
- Gibeyes Wrap
- $9.05
Appetizers
- Bosco Sticks
- 4 for $7.99 · 8 for $11.99
- Beer-Battered Fried Mushrooms
- $7.35
- Potato Skins
- 6 for $10.35
- Loaded Fries
- $11.35
- Ravioli
- $7.95
- French Fries
- $5.25
- Mac & Cheese Bites
- 8 for $7.95
- Beer-Battered Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
- 5 for $9.35
- Tater Kegs
- 5 for $8.55
- Jalapeño Poppers
- $8.95
- Green Beans
- $6.95
- Breaded Fried Pickle Chips
- $7.35
- Pretzel Bites
- 12 for $9.45
- Pepperoni Bites
- $5.95
- Garlic Bread with Cheese
- $7.05
- Breaded Chicken Tenders
- 4 for $7.55
- Breaded Shrimp
- $9.25
Wings
Sauces: Hot, Medium, Nashville Hot, BBQ, Garlic Parm, Sweet Chili, Garlic Buffalo, Jamaican Jerk, Hot Honey, Mango Habanero.
- Bone-In Wings
- 6 for $9.05 · 12 for $17.05 · 24 for $33.65
- Boneless Wings
- ½ lb $8.65 · 1 lb $17.05
Salads
Dressings: Italian, Fat-Free Italian, Honey Mustard, Thousand Island, Ranch, French, Bleu Cheese. Add grilled or breaded chicken: small $1.95 / large $2.25.
- Garden Salad
- Small $5.65
- Chef Salad
- Small $7.05 · Large $11.25
- Meat Salad
- Small $6.75 · Large $10.45
Pasta
Served with garlic bread.
- Baked Penne Alfredo & Chicken
- $11.75
- Baked Penne Pasta & Meatballs
- $12.05
Stromboli
Includes cheese and your choice of one topping.
- Stromboli
- $16.05 · Additional toppings $2.35 each
- Stromizza
- 14″ half pizza, half stromboli · $21.95
Burgers
Fries included except with the plain hamburger. Make it a double for $3.99 more.
- Jalapeño Burger
- $13.95
- BBQ Bacon Burger
- $12.95
- Ashley Classic Burger
- $12.05
- Hamburger
- $9.95
Kids
Served with a choice of fries or potato chips.
- Mini Corn Dogs
- $7.05
- Chicken Tenders
- $6.95
- Personal Pizza
- One item · $8.99
Desserts
- Big Ole Brownie or Cookie
- $7.15 · Ice cream cup +$2.35
- Funnel Cake Fries
- 15 for $7.55
- Apple Dessert Pizza
- 12″ · $10.95
- Mini Peanut Butter Explosion Cake
- $6.25
Sides of sauce
- Ranch
- $0.99
- Beer Cheese
- $1.99
- Garlic Butter
- $1.09
- Bleu Cheese
- $1.15
- Sour Cream
- $1.29
- Marinara
- $1.15
- Hot or Medium
- $1.55
- Honey Mustard
- $0.99
Catering
We cater events in and around Ashley, Ohio. Call (740) 747-2961 or email Gibeyespizzaandpub@gmail.com and we’ll put together a spread for your party.
Catering Chicken Wings With Bone$70.00
50 ct.
Catering Garlic Bread$49.50
24 ct.
Catering Size Bosco Sticks$32.55
24 ct.
Catering Chicken Breast Tenders$110.00
50 ct.
Catering Size Salad$39.95
Giant 24″ Party Pizza$26.95
Additional toppings extra.
Catering Italian Sub Platter
- Small · feeds approx. 8
- $44.05
- Large · feeds approx. 16
- $88.05
Catering Meatballs In Sauce$65.00
Catering Spaghetti And Sauce$70.00
Catering Chicken Alfredo Penne Pasta$80.00
Catering Penne Pasta and Meatballs$85.00
All items served in full size foil pans.
Most items require lead time. Please call us at (740) 747-2961 to place your order.
Prices shown are from our 2026 menu. Check online ordering for current availability. The consumption of raw or undercooked eggs, meat, poultry, seafood or shellfish may increase your risk of food-borne illness.